Skip to content
Term: --%

Election-fraud special · Updated 06/11/2026

43,000 votes from Skid Row didn't steal an election. Reality did.

Reality-TV star Spencer Pratt held second place on election night in the June 2026 Los Angeles mayor's race - ahead of Nithya Raman for the second runoff spot - then slipped to third as the later ballots were counted. He, Elon Musk and Donald Trump called it fraud from Skid Row; Pratt formally conceded, but kept calling the count 'evidence of fraud'. The real cases anywhere near it are about petitions, not votes: a circulator who paid people a couple of dollars to fill in registration forms, months earlier, for nobody in particular - now sentenced to probation - and three circulators indicted in September, accused but not convicted, of paying people to forge voters' signatures on initiative petitions. As of 5 November 2026 no audit, recount, lawsuit or prosecution we could find showed a single vote stolen in the mayor's race. On 3 November Raman beat Bass in the runoff; AP called it on 5 November and Bass conceded the same day. This is what a furphy looks like, sourced end to end.

25.5%
Pratt's actual third-place finish, behind Raman on 29.0% and Bass on 34.3% - 29,804 votes short of the runoff LA County Registrar-Recorder results
4
people federally charged over two Skid Row petition schemes - one convicted over paid registration forms and sentenced to probation, three indicted (allegations only) over forged petition signatures. None for casting or buying a vote. U.S. DOJ, Sep 2026
+20 pts
Harris's real, counted 2024 California margin over Trump - a genuine 20-point landslide Politico results
0
evidence any scheme changed a result, per LA County, the DOJ and election experts LA Times

01 The furphy

Third place, then a conspiracy theory.

Spencer Pratt - reality-TV star turned Republican candidate - sat in second place on election night in the June 2026 Los Angeles mayor's race. As the mail ballots were verified and counted over the following days, City Councilmember Nithya Raman climbed past him and took the runoff spot against Mayor Karen Bass. Pratt conceded the race, but not the arithmetic: he never accepted that the later ballots had simply broken against him, and he insinuated fraud.

Elon Musk reposted Pratt's video with four words: 'California has legalized election fraud.' Trump declared the race 'rigged' and told Pratt not to 'go away quietly.' Between the three of them, the evidence produced was zero.

Sources: Forbes: Musk boosts Pratt's 'legalized election fraud' claim (09/07/2026); LA County Registrar-Recorder: Los Angeles mayor primary results, 2 June 2026; CBS News: Raman defeats Pratt to face Bass in runoff.

The claim, in their own words

Spencer Pratt: An anomalous statistical spike like this is evidence of fraud... it may not necessarily be proof of fraud, but it is certainly evidence of fraud. The maths problem: Late mail ballots breaking against a Republican is not a spike. It is every California count. Spencer Pratt: [43,000] just happens to be the exact number of homeless people on the streets in LA. The insinuation: That Skid Row somehow cast tens of thousands of ballots for his opponents. No one has produced evidence it did. Elon Musk: California has legalized election fraud. The amplifier: Reposted to hundreds of millions of followers. Evidence attached: none. Donald Trump: RIGGED. The president: Trump called the LA race rigged, urged Pratt not to 'go away quietly,' and claimed California's Republican governor nominee was 'cheated' too. No receipts for any of it.

02 The count

What the ballots actually did.

California is a universal vote-by-mail state: every registered voter is posted a ballot. Those ballots are returned and signature-verified over days, and the ones counted later lean Democratic, because Democrats vote by mail in far greater numbers than Republicans. So the count on election night looked better for the Republican - and then, as more of the mail was verified and added, it didn't. That swing is the entire 'anomaly.'

Final primary result: Karen Bass 34.3%, Nithya Raman 29.0%, Spencer Pratt 25.5%. The top two advance to the November runoff. Pratt finished third, about three and a half points - 29,804 votes - behind Raman for that second spot. There is no fraud in coming third. Then came the runoff on 3 November 2026, and the mail did it again, this time to a Democrat: Bass led the early returns, the later ballots broke to Raman, and AP called the race for Raman on 5 November with Raman on 52.1% to Bass's 47.9% (429,450 to 394,796). Bass conceded that day: 'I have called Councilmember Nithya Raman to congratulate her on her victory.' The result was not yet certified, with more than 700,000 ballots still to count across the county. Pratt's verdict: 'Nithya didn't win. Karen lost.' No fraud claim attached.

Sources: LA County Registrar-Recorder: Los Angeles mayor primary results, 2 June 2026; CBS News: Raman defeats Pratt to face Bass in runoff; Wikipedia: 2026 Los Angeles mayoral election; ABC7: county certifies the primary; how each neighbourhood voted (29/07/2026); ABC7: Bass concedes to Raman; AP projects Raman the winner; Raman 429,450 to Bass 394,796 (05/11/2026); Al Jazeera / AP: Nithya Raman wins the LA mayoral race, becoming the city's first South Asian mayor (05/11/2026); FOX 11: LA mayor race election results; Us Weekly: Spencer Pratt reacts to the Los Angeles mayor race results (05/11/2026).

From an election-night lead to third place, and then a runoff

02/06/2026 - Election night: Pratt sits in second, ahead of Raman, on the ballots counted first. 03-08/06 - The later ballots: The county keeps verifying and counting mail and cure ballots. Raman climbs and passes Pratt, as later-counted ballots reliably break. 08/06/2026 - Runoff set: Raman takes second. The November runoff is Bass v Raman. Pratt is eliminated in third. Final - Bass 34.3% - Raman 29.0% - Pratt 25.5%: Pratt finished third by about three and a half points, 29,804 votes. No candidate cleared 50%, so the top two advance. The county certified the result. We found no recount, audit or lawsuit that turned up fraud. 03/11/2026 - Runoff day: Bass v Raman. Bass leads the early returns; as later ballots are counted, they break to Raman. 05/11/2026 - Raman wins; Bass concedes: AP calls the race for Raman shortly before noon, 52.1% to 47.9% on the latest count. Bass concedes the same day. Not yet certified, with more than 700,000 ballots still to count countywide. No fraud claim from Pratt, Musk or Trump that we could find.

03 The maths

The 'red mirage' is not a crime scene.

The pattern Pratt calls fraud has a boring name that election officials have used for years: the red mirage, or the blue shift. Republicans tend to vote in person; Democrats vote by mail; mail takes longer to verify and count. So Republican leads on election night shrink as the mail is tallied. It happens in state after state, cycle after cycle. It is arithmetic, and it is predicted in advance.

The viral 'Pratt got zero votes in a 24,000-ballot drop' clip was a screenshot of a news site caught mid-update, before Pratt's share of that batch loaded. The Justice Department reviewed the county's official records and confirmed every candidate received votes in every update.

Sources: Forbes: 'Red Mirage' explanation and DOJ debunk of the zero-votes claim; LA Times: how a simple mix-up fuelled false claims about the LA count; California SoS: vote-by-mail signature verification and ballot tracking; Orange County Registrar: 2024 risk-limiting audit, zero discrepancies (PDF).

Claim vs receipt

Claim: A statistical spike this big is evidence of fraud. Receipt: It's the blue shift. Later-counted mail ballots tend to skew Democratic, because Democrats vote by mail more. It is predicted before elections and seen after them, in California and beyond. Claim: Pratt got 0 votes in an overnight drop of 24,000 ballots. Receipt: A screenshot of a staggered news-site update, grabbed before his share of the batch posted. The DOJ checked the county's own records: every candidate got votes in every batch. Claim: You can't audit or verify any of it anyway. Receipt: Every mail envelope is signature-checked, voters track ballots with 'Where's My Ballot,' and California audits results with a 1% manual tally or a risk-limiting audit. When Orange County ran a risk-limiting audit on its 2024 count, it found zero discrepancies.

04 Skid Row

There are real cases. They're the opposite of 43,000 votes.

Here is the steelman, because a real investigation gives the other side its best shot. In May 2026 the Justice Department did charge someone connected to Skid Row: Brenda Lee Brown Armstrong, 64, a signature-gatherer who agreed to plead guilty to one felony count of paying another person to register to vote. She pleaded guilty in June, and on 31 August 2026 she was sentenced to 18 months' probation and 120 hours of community service. No prison. In September a second case followed, and it is still only an indictment.

What she actually did: for about twenty years she periodically worked as a paid 'petition circulator,' earning a set fee per valid signature on ballot measures. She paid Skid Row residents $2-$3 to sign her petitions and, from 2025, also to complete voter-registration forms so more of her signatures would count. For a few people with no fixed address, she wrote her own former address. What she did NOT do, per the DOJ's own charge, is pay anyone to vote, or to vote for a candidate, or touch the mayor's race - the charged act was back in January 2026, and the DOJ ties it to none of the June contest. One person padding a signature business is not 43,000 phantom voters. The second case is the same trade with a nastier twist. In September a federal grand jury indicted James Brass, 47, of Victorville, who ran a team of petition circulators, along with two of them, Courtney Price, 49, and Jateisha Herron, 33. Prosecutors allege they handed out the stolen identities of registered voters and paid people on Skid Row to copy those voters' details onto ballot-initiative petitions and sign in their names, between February and August 2026, and that Brass was paid about $41,600 by coordinators working with a petition management company. The charges are conspiracy to commit identity fraud, plus identity fraud for Brass and Price, with a maximum of five years per count. They are allegations, not convictions. And again, look at what is missing: no ballot cast, no vote bought, nothing about the mayor's race. Forged petition signatures are a real crime against direct democracy; they are not a stolen election.

Sources: U.S. DOJ: Marina del Rey woman charged over Skid Row registration payments (18/05/2026); NBC Los Angeles: woman charged with paying homeless people to register to vote; LA Times: unfounded claims of homeless voter fraud - we went to Skid Row; KESQ / City News Service: Armstrong sentenced to 18 months' probation and 120 hours' community service (31/08/2026); U.S. DOJ: Brass, Price and Herron charged over Skid Row petition signatures using stolen voter identities (14/09/2026); NBC Los Angeles: Victorville man arrested over Skid Row ballot-petition signatures (09/2026).

The real cases, by the numbers

1 - person convicted: Not 43,000. One signature-gatherer, who pleaded guilty to a single count of paying people to register. Probation - her sentence, 31 Aug 2026: 18 months' probation and 120 hours of community service. No prison. $2-$3 - paid per signature: Cash for petition signatures, and from 2025 registration forms. Her paid signature trade ran about 20 years. 3 - indicted, Sep 2026: Accused of forging voters' signatures on initiative petitions with stolen identities. Allegations, not convictions. 0 - votes bought: Neither case alleges anyone paid for a vote, cast a fake ballot, or touched the mayor's race. Jan 2026 - Armstrong's charged act: Months before the June primary, and unconnected to the mayor's race.

05 The pattern

He's run this play on California since 2016.

The Skid Row furphy is not new; it's the latest instalment. Trump has called California's elections stolen for a decade, always the same way: a huge, evidence-free claim, released just before or right after a result he dislikes, aimed at the biggest blue state. California has 54 electoral votes, a roughly 2-to-1 Democratic registration edge, and it is the state whose four-million-vote margin single-handedly cost him the 2016 popular vote.

Zoom out, and the pattern looked built to pre-discredit November 2026: brand California's mail ballots as fraud in advance, then dispute the midterm the way 2020 was disputed - loudly, by people who never produce the evidence, in a state he was always going to lose. Then November actually happened. The Justice Department's late bid to make California set aside about 20,000 mail ballots was refused by a district judge and then by the Ninth Circuit before polling day. It also subpoenaed Los Angeles County registrar staff to appear before a grand jury on 4 November; we found no report of any election official being charged as of 5 November. What the US attorney in Los Angeles did announce on 4 November was indictments of 10 green-card holders accused of registering illegally at various points between 2002 and 2024, five of whom allegedly voted or cast a provisional ballot in elections from 2020 to 2024. Allegations, not convictions - and if proven, a real crime - but that is ten people over two decades, none in 2026, not 20,000 and not 43,000. On 3 November Trump told the New York Times he was 'absolutely willing to accept' the results. Steve Hilton - the Republican Trump said was 'cheated' in June - lost the governor's race to Xavier Becerra and conceded on election night: 'Maybe this isn't the best year to be running for office as a Republican.' Pratt greeted Raman's win with mockery, not a fraud claim: 'This wasn't an election... it was a humiliation ritual.' As of 5 November 2026 we found no claim by Trump, Musk or Pratt that California's November results were rigged. Funny how the furphy only gets a run when it's useful.

Sources: PolitiFact: Trump's 'millions voted illegally' - Pants on Fire (2016); FactCheck.org: Trump's 'million California votes' twist on a roll-cleanup settlement (2019); PolitiFact: Prop 50 was not 'rigged' (05/11/2025); FactCheck.org: fact-checking Trump's 16/07/2026 election-security speech; Brennan Center: the March 2025 elections executive order, blocked in court; California SoS: Report of Registration - Democrats outnumber Republicans about 2-to-1; Al Jazeera: Trump administration sues California over noncitizens on voter rolls (15/10/2026); PBS NewsHour / AP: appeals court rejects DOJ request for California to set aside disputed ballots (30/10/2026); ABC7 / ABC News: DOJ issues grand jury subpoenas to California election officials (30/10/2026); U.S. Attorney, C.D. Cal.: grand jury indicts 10 noncitizens accused of registering illegally - allegations only (04/11/2026); UW Center for an Informed Public: election rumours quiet after Trump acknowledges Republican losses (04/11/2026); KPBS: Democrat Xavier Becerra wins California governor's race, defeating Republican Steve Hilton (03/11/2026); The Hollywood Reporter: Hilton concedes the California governor's race (04/11/2026); Us Weekly: Spencer Pratt reacts to the Los Angeles mayor race results (05/11/2026).

A decade of the same claim

Claim: 'Millions voted illegally - that's why I lost California.' (2016) Receipt: PolitiFact: Pants on Fire. No evidence was ever produced. Clinton won California by 4.27 million real, counted votes. Claim: 'California admitted to a million illegal votes.' (2019) Receipt: It was a settlement to tidy inactive registrations off the rolls - people who'd moved or died. It admitted no fraud and named no illegal votes. Claim: 'The Prop 50 redistricting vote is a GIANT SCAM... RIGGED.' (Nov 2025) Receipt: Posted the morning of the vote. Prop 50 passed comfortably, and courts tossed the Republican lawsuit. PolitiFact: rigging it would take a statewide criminal conspiracy of election officials, and there is no evidence of one. Claim: 278,000 noncitizens are on the rolls, up to 190,832 of them in California. (Jul 2026) Receipt: The DHS numbers came with no methodology, and fact-checkers call them 'likely highly inaccurate.' Past DHS-derived lists have repeatedly flagged actual citizens, especially the recently naturalised. Claim: 'We'll require proof of citizenship to fix it.' (EO, Mar 2025) Receipt: A federal court permanently blocked the mandate in October 2025 - the president doesn't set voter-registration rules. A court threw out the DOJ's demand for California's voter file too. Claim: Set aside the ballots sent to about 20,000 possible noncitizens, uncounted until citizenship is checked. (DOJ lawsuit, Oct 2026) Receipt: California officials said the list was highly unreliable and likely includes many citizens. A district judge refused on 28 October, saying it would 'wreak havoc'; on 30 October the Ninth Circuit agreed 2-1, in an opinion co-written by a Trump appointee: 'there is no feasible way to identify and segregate the ballots of specific individuals without potentially catastrophic effects on the entire system.'

06 Verdict

Grade F: a third-place finish, dressed up as a heist.

Strip out the celebrity and the ALL-CAPS and here is what remains: a Republican came third in a heavily Democratic city, the later ballots broke the way later ballots reliably break, and one petition circulator was convicted for padding her signature business with $2 registration forms - and got probation. A second petition crew has since been indicted, accused (not convicted) of forging voters' signatures; still no votes. From that, Trump, Musk and Pratt manufactured 'California has legalized election fraud.'

A furphy is a rumour dressed up as a fact. This is a furphy. Every receipt is in this report, and not one of them shows a stolen election - only a losing candidate blaming Skid Row instead of the voters of Los Angeles. Five months on, as of 5 November 2026, no audit, recount, lawsuit or prosecution we could find has turned up a single stolen vote in the mayor's race. And in November the same 'rigged' system cost the incumbent Democrat her job: Raman beat Bass, Bass conceded, and nobody in the fraud brigade alleged fraud.

Sources: LA Times: experts say one-off Skid Row cases could not change the outcome; Forbes: the claims, amplified without evidence; LA County Registrar-Recorder: the actual primary result; U.S. DOJ: the first real, narrow case (charged May 2026); KESQ: the sentence - 18 months' probation (31/08/2026); U.S. DOJ: the second case - a petition-signature indictment, allegations only (14/09/2026); ABC7: Bass concedes; AP projects Raman the winner (05/11/2026).

The furphy, scored

Editorial grade F. The insinuation was 43,000 stolen votes. The reality is one probation sentence, one petition indictment, zero votes bought for a candidate, and a runoff spot Pratt lost by about three and a half points. The insinuation: 43,000 'stolen' votes. The reality: 1 conviction (probation), 1 indictment - both petitions. Votes bought for a candidate: 0. Who took the runoff spot: Raman, by ~3.5 pts. Who won the runoff: Raman, 52.1% (AP call, 5 Nov).

· Source rule

Every claim gets a receipt.

This investigation steelmans the fraud case before dismantling it: it quotes Pratt, Musk and Trump directly, credits the one real charge the DOJ actually filed, and then measures both against the official count. If a line sounds sharp, the source underneath it is still doing the work.

Core sources: the U.S. Department of Justice, the Los Angeles Times, the Associated Press, CBS News, Forbes, PolitiFact, FactCheck.org, the California Secretary of State, the Orange County Registrar, the Brennan Center and Politico.