The Register / Locked November 2024
What we agreed in November 2024.
Eleven promises, each with a target and all but one with a baseline, agreed before he took office. One of us loves him and one of us doesn't. We both signed off these numbers, and they do not move.
Agreed by Mike (Trump Hater) and Steve (Trump Lover). Latest check-in: Year 1, . Overall grade: D+, an editorial judgement rather than a published arithmetic average.
How this works
The goalposts stay put.
The register
The promise, baseline and target for each metric, and the deadline we read into it. The agreed wording sits word for word beside the labels the scorecard uses. Neither gets edited, even where an agreed number has aged badly.
The check-ins
Once a year we record each result, grade and verdict, with sources. A new year adds an entry. Old entries stay as recorded, swearing and all.
The lock
Our validator fails if anyone edits the register or a past check-in. Changing either means deliberately updating its recorded fingerprint.
The eleven
Baseline to target, at a glance.
Metric 1 of 11 · Economy
Onshore Manufacturing
Bring manufacturing back to America. Boost output by ~20%.
As agreed, November 2024
Onshore Manufacturing
- Baseline
U.S. manufacturing output is about $2.3 trillion per year.
- Target
Increase output by 20% to roughly $2.76 trillion per year.
- Measurement
Compare BEA industrial production data over the term.
On the scorecard
- Baseline
- $2.3 trillion
As of 2024 (agreed baseline) - Target
- $2.76 trillion (+20%)
- Deadline
- End of term (20/01/2029)
- Locked
- November 2024
How we read it: The agreed measure names BEA industrial production data, but industrial production is a Federal Reserve index. BEA publishes manufacturing value added and gross output. The scorecard compares the agreed dollar figures with manufacturing value added and uses the Federal Reserve index for the trend.
Check-ins
Year 1
Grade C
- Result
- $2.96 trillion (value added, Q4 2025)
- Trend
- +1.3% YoY (industrial production index, April 2026)
- Change from baseline
- +28.7%
- Progress to target
- 100%
- Figures as of
- Q4 2025
Verdict: Hit the target on paper. Real growth: a rounding error. He's taking credit for the trend.
Method: Level from manufacturing value added for Q4 2025, as reported by NAM; trend from the Federal Reserve industrial production index. The FRED GOMA link is BEA gross output, a different and larger measure, listed for context.
Sources: BEA Gross Output by Industry: Manufacturing (FRED GOMA); Federal Reserve G.17 Industrial Production, April 2026; NAM Manufacturing Facts (Q4 2025 value added).
Year 2
Not checked yet.
Year 3
Not checked yet.
Year 4
Not checked yet.
Metric 2 of 11 · Trade
Trade Deficit with China
Slash the U.S. trade deficit with China by 30%.
As agreed, November 2024
Trade Deficit with China
- Baseline
Approximately $300 billion deficit with China.
- Target
Reduce the deficit by 30%, bringing it to about $210 billion.
- Measurement
Use trade and customs data from the U.S. Census Bureau.
On the scorecard
- Baseline
- $300B deficit
As of 2024 (agreed baseline) - Target
- $210B (-30%)
- Deadline
- End of term (20/01/2029)
- Locked
- November 2024
Check-ins
Year 1
Grade B
- Result
- $202B deficit (2025 annual)
- Change from baseline
- -32.7%
- Progress to target
- 100%
- Figures as of
- 2025 full year
Verdict: Number down. Wallets down further. Americans paid the bill, not Beijing.
Sources: Statista: U.S.-China Trade Volume and Balance; USNews: U.S. Trade Deficit Declined in 2025; Yale Budget Lab: State of U.S. Tariffs; SCOTUSblog: Trump v. V.O.S. Selections.
Year 2
Not checked yet.
Year 3
Not checked yet.
Year 4
Not checked yet.
Metric 3 of 11 · Crime & Safety
Violent Crime Reduction
Cut violent crime in major U.S. cities by 15%.
As agreed, November 2024
Crime Reduction (Violent Crime)
- Baseline
Major cities registering around 400 violent crime incidents per 100,000 residents.
- Target
Achieve a 15% reduction, lowering the rate to about 340 incidents per 100,000 residents.
- Measurement
Rely on local and FBI crime statistics.
On the scorecard
- Baseline
- ~400 incidents per 100k (major cities)
As of 2024 (agreed baseline) - Target
- 340 per 100k (-15%)
- Deadline
- End of term (20/01/2029)
- Locked
- November 2024
Check-ins
Year 1
Grade B
- Result
- Homicides -17 to -21%, gun assaults -21 to -22%, robberies -20 to -23% YoY across major cities (2025)
- Recorded change
- -18%
- Progress to target
- 100%
- Figures as of
- 2025 year-end (Council on Criminal Justice)
Verdict: Crime fell. Trump had fuck-all to do with it. Trend started in 2022.
Method: Measured with the Council on Criminal Justice sample of 40 large cities. CCJ reports rates and changes offence by offence, not one violent-crime rate comparable with the agreed 400 per 100,000. So the -18% recorded in Year 1 is not a measured change from that baseline.
Sources: Council on Criminal Justice: Crime Trends Year-End 2025; Axios: Violent crime falls across major U.S. cities; Officer.com: Report Shows Steep Decline in Major Cities 2025.
Year 2
Not checked yet.
Year 3
Not checked yet.
Year 4
Not checked yet.
Metric 4 of 11 · Public Health
Fentanyl Crisis
Reduce fentanyl overdose deaths by 25%.
As agreed, November 2024
Fentanyl Crisis
- Baseline
An estimated 50,000 fentanyl‐related overdose deaths per year nationwide.
- Target
Reduce these deaths by 25% to near 37,500 annually.
- Measurement
Track through CDC and state public health data.
On the scorecard
- Baseline
- ~50,000 fentanyl-related deaths / year
As of 2024 (agreed baseline) - Target
- ~37,500 / year (-25%)
- Deadline
- End of term (20/01/2029)
- Locked
- November 2024
Check-ins
Year 1
Grade B
- Result
- ~47,000-48,000 synthetic opioid deaths (12 mo to end-2025)
- Change from baseline
- -5%
- Progress to target
- 20%
- Figures as of
- 12 months ending 2025
Verdict: Deaths down. Biden's policies, mostly. He's standing in front of someone else's progress wearing a borrowed sash.
Method: Measured with CDC provisional deaths from synthetic opioids, the category that includes fentanyl.
Sources: CDC Provisional Drug Overdose Death Data Dashboard; USNews: CDC Reports 14% Drop in Overdose Deaths 2025; AJMC: Drug Overdoses Drop 14% in 2025.
Year 2
Not checked yet.
Year 3
Not checked yet.
Year 4
Not checked yet.
Metric 5 of 11 · Energy
Energy Independence
Drill, baby, drill. Boost oil and gas output by 40%.
As agreed, November 2024
Energy Independence
- Baseline
Oil production: ~11 million barrels per day (mb/d).
Natural gas production: ~90 billion cubic feet per day (bcf/d).
- Target
Increase by 40%: roughly 15.4 mb/d for oil and 126 bcf/d for natural gas.
- Measurement
Compare against Department of Energy production statistics.
On the scorecard
- Baseline
- Oil ~11 Mb/d, gas ~90 Bcf/d
As of 2024 (agreed baseline) - Target
- Oil 15.4 Mb/d, gas 126 Bcf/d (+40%)
- Deadline
- End of term (20/01/2029)
- Locked
- November 2024
How we read it: The 40% target applies to oil and gas alike. The locked target value is the oil figure, so progress percentages are calculated on oil.
Check-ins
Year 1
Grade D
- Result
- Oil ~13.5 Mb/d, gas ~107.7 Bcf/d (EIA 2025)
- Change from baseline
- +22.7%
- Progress to target
- 57%
- Figures as of
- EIA Short-Term Energy Outlook, 2025-2026
Verdict: Flat. The 'energy DOMINANCE' rally chant ran into reality: oil prices fell, drillers stopped drilling.
Method: The change and progress figures are for oil only.
Sources: EIA Short-Term Energy Outlook; EnergyNow: EIA Forecast U.S. Oil Production 2025-2026; GasBuddy 2026 Fuel Price Outlook; PolitiFact: Reduce gas below $2/gallon (Stalled).
Year 2
Not checked yet.
Year 3
Not checked yet.
Year 4
Not checked yet.
Metric 6 of 11 · Immigration
Border Security
Build 500 miles of new border wall and cut illegal crossings by 50%.
As agreed, November 2024
Border Security
- Baseline
Wall Construction: 0 new miles built in the term.
Illegal Crossings: Approximately 500,000 detected per year.
- Target
Build 500 miles of new border wall.
Reduce illegal crossings by 50% (to about 250,000 annually).
- Measurement
Verify through government construction reports and border patrol data.
On the scorecard
- Baseline
- 0 new miles, ~500,000 illegal crossings / year
- Target
- 500 new miles, ~250,000 crossings / year (-50%)
- Deadline
- Not stated; read as the end of term (20/01/2029)
- Locked
- November 2024
How we read it: Two targets in one: illegal crossings and new wall miles. Each is measured separately and the single grade covers both.
Check-ins
Year 1
Grade B
- Crossings
- 237,538 apprehensions (FY2025) - lowest since 1970; 100% of target
- New wall
- ~25-78 new miles (depending on definition; CBP Smart Wall Map); 10% of target
- Figures as of
- FY2025 end (Sept 2025) / CBP May 2026
Verdict: Crossings smashed. Wall: 10-15% of what he promised, and he's still saying he built it. Lying as he breathes.
Sources: CBP Smart Wall Map; Pew Research: Migrant encounters at 50-year low; Axios: ICE deported 442k in FY2025; Newsweek: ICE Missing Trump Admin Deportation Target.
Year 2
Not checked yet.
Year 3
Not checked yet.
Year 4
Not checked yet.
Metric 7 of 11 · Healthcare
Healthcare Costs (Prescription Drugs)
Cut prescription drug out-of-pocket costs by 20%.
As agreed, November 2024
Healthcare Costs (Prescription Drugs)
- Baseline
Average out-of-pocket cost for prescription drugs is around $100 per month per patient.
- Target
Lower costs by 20% to approximately $80 per month.
- Measurement
Track changes in pricing data from healthcare expenditure reports.
On the scorecard
- Baseline
- $100 / month average out-of-pocket
As of 2024 (agreed baseline) - Target
- $80 / month (-20%)
- Deadline
- End of term (20/01/2029)
- Locked
- November 2024
Check-ins
Year 1
Grade F
- Result
- No measurable change to typical patient out-of-pocket costs
- Progress to target
- 5%
- Figures as of
- October 2025 (Forbes analysis)
Verdict: Signed an executive order, held the photo op, drug prices unchanged. The pharma lobby wrote him a thank you card.
Method: No dollar figure was recorded against the $100 baseline. The grade rests on analysis showing no measurable change for typical patients.
Sources: Executive Order 14297: Most-Favored-Nation Drug Pricing; Forbes: Trump's Drug Price Initiative Has No Impact On Typical Patients; Georgetown: Drug Pricing in the Era of Trump 2.0.
Year 2
Not checked yet.
Year 3
Not checked yet.
Year 4
Not checked yet.
Metric 8 of 11 · Fiscal
Government Efficiency (DOGE)
Cut $1-2 trillion in federal spending via DOGE.
As agreed, November 2024
Government Efficiency (DOGE Savings)
- Baseline
Estimated annual federal spending stands around $6.5 trillion (on areas that could be trimmed or made more efficient).
- Target
Realize overall savings of $1–$2 trillion over the term through aggressive budget cuts, streamlined agencies, and workforce efficiencies.
- Measurement
Monitor quarterly and annual budget reports to track cumulative spending cuts relative to projected expenditures.
On the scorecard
- Baseline
- ~$6.5 trillion federal outlays
As of FY2024 - Target
- $1-2 trillion cumulative savings
- Deadline
- End of term (20/01/2029)
- Locked
- November 2024
How we read it: The agreed target is a range of $1-2 trillion. The locked target value is the $1.5 trillion midpoint, which is the yardstick for progress percentages.
Check-ins
Year 1
Grade F
- Claimed
- $214 billion (DOGE.gov)
- Recorded as "verified"
- ~$110 billion verified via 'receipts' (~51% of claim)
- Federal outlays
- $6.6 trillion (FY2025) - UP 6% YoY
- Offsetting costs
- $135 billion in layoff disruption costs (Partnership for Public Service estimate, reported by CBS)
- Deficit
- Still above $1.8 trillion
- Progress to target
- 7%
- Figures as of
- Early 2026
Verdict: Numbers cooked, deficit UP, spending UP, Musk fired, Musk sued, Musk now hates him. Comedy gold, fiscal disaster.
Year 1 method note (later corrected): Progress is verified savings (about $110 billion) against the $1.5 trillion midpoint.
Correction, 16/11/2026: The Year 1 archive's DOGE figures predate the GAO audit. GAO reports $110.34 billion in DOGE-reported savings as of 7 July 2026 (rounded to $110 billion in its highlights) and finds some estimates incorrect or unsupported; it does not certify the total as realised savings. Treasury reports FY2025 outlays of $7.010 trillion, up 4.1%, and a $1.775 trillion deficit, down $42 billion. Annual totals do not establish DOGE-specific cumulative savings against a counterfactual. Sources and full note.
Sources: DOGE.gov Savings (official tally); POLITICO: Just how much has DOGE exaggerated its numbers?; CBS News: DOGE cuts cost taxpayers $135B; Quartz: Did DOGE actually save the US money? The numbers say no; Al Jazeera: Has DOGE really saved the US government $180bn?; Pew Research: federal workforce shrank 10% in Trump's first year back in office.
Year 2
Not checked yet.
Year 3
Not checked yet.
Year 4
Not checked yet.
Metric 9 of 11 · Economy
GDP Growth
Grow nominal GDP by 10-15% over the term.
As agreed, November 2024
GDP Growth
- Baseline
U.S. nominal GDP is about $25 trillion.
- Target
Increase GDP by 10–15%, reaching roughly $27.5–$28.75 trillion over the term.
- Measurement
Use quarterly and annual GDP reports from the BEA to gauge progress.
On the scorecard
- Baseline
- $25 trillion nominal GDP
As of 2024 (agreed baseline; outdated) - Target
- $27.5-$28.75T (+10-15%)
- Deadline
- End of term (20/01/2029)
- Locked
- November 2024
How we read it: The agreed target is a range of 10-15%. The locked target value is the top of that range, $28.75 trillion. The scorecard flags the agreed $25 trillion baseline as outdated but keeps it, as agreed.
Check-ins
Year 1
Grade B
- Result
- $31.86T (Q1 2026 nominal, BEA advance estimate)
- Change from baseline
- +27.4%
- Progress to target
- 100%
- Figures as of
- Q1 2026 BEA
Verdict: Met the bar. Mostly because the baseline was wrong. He's surfing a wave he didn't make.
Sources: BEA Quarterly GDP Release; Moody's Analytics: U.S. Nominal GDP; FactCheck.org: Trump's Numbers, April 2026 Update.
Year 2
Not checked yet.
Year 3
Not checked yet.
Year 4
Not checked yet.
Metric 10 of 11 · Economy
Productivity Boost
Lift labor productivity by 10% over the term.
As agreed, November 2024
Productivity Boost
- Baseline
Labor productivity is estimated at $70 of output per hour worked.
- Target
Achieve a 10% improvement to about $77 of output per hour worked.
- Measurement
Compare labor productivity data over the term.
On the scorecard
- Baseline
- $70 output per hour
As of 2024 (agreed baseline) - Target
- $77 / hour (+10%)
- Deadline
- End of term (20/01/2029)
- Locked
- November 2024
Check-ins
Year 1
Grade B
- Result
- +2.2% annual (BLS nonfarm business, 2025); +2.8% YoY Q4 2025
- Progress to target
- 22%
- Figures as of
- BLS 2025 annual + Q4 2025
Verdict: Normal pace. Not driven by anything Trump did. He'd take credit for the sunrise if his speechwriter let him.
Method: Measured with BLS nonfarm business productivity growth, a percentage change rather than a dollar figure per hour.
Sources: BLS Productivity and Costs; Young Research: U.S. Nonfarm Productivity Rises 2.8% in Q4 2025.
Year 2
Not checked yet.
Year 3
Not checked yet.
Year 4
Not checked yet.
Metric 11 of 11 · Foreign Policy
End the Ukraine War on Day 1
End the Ukraine war on Day 1 of his term. ('I'll have it settled in 24 hours.')
As agreed, November 2024
Ending the Ukraine War on Day 1
- Baseline
None in the agreed list.
- Target
A binary outcome: on Day 1 of Trumps term, the war in Ukraine must be officially ended.
- Measurement
None in the agreed list.
On the scorecard
- Baseline
- Active war as of Jan 20, 2025
- Target
- War ended on or before Jan 20, 2025
- Deadline
- Day 1 (20/01/2025)
- Measured
- Binary: either the war was officially ended on Day 1 (20/01/2025) or it was not.
- Locked
- November 2024
How we read it: The agreed list sets no baseline or measurement source. The scorecard records the war as active on 20/01/2025.
Check-ins
Year 1
Grade F
- Result
- Active war as of May 24, 2026. A 3-day U.S.-mediated humanitarian truce in May 2026 collapsed in under 12 hours.
- Days late
- 489
- Progress to target
- 0%
- Figures as of
- May 2026
Verdict: 489 days late and counting. 'I'll end it in 24 hours.' He didn't end it in 24 hours, 24 weeks, or 24 months. Putin's still winning. Trump's still preening.
Sources: Reuters/Stripes: Trump announces 3-day ceasefire (May 2026); Wikipedia: May 2026 Russo-Ukrainian truce; Michael Hollister: Russia-Ukraine Conflict Update May 21 2026.
Year 2
Not checked yet.
Year 3
Not checked yet.
Year 4
Not checked yet.
Dated corrections
What later evidence changed.
These notes update the interpretation of later evidence. They do not rewrite the locked November 2024 agreement or the archived Year 1 check-in.
Ukraine ceasefire wording
The Year 1 archive and earlier site copy said the May 2026 ceasefire collapsed in under 12 hours. The agreement was announced for May 9-11; reports described fighting and mutual accusations of violations during that period. The cited sources do not establish a 12-hour collapse. The Day 1 promise failure is unchanged.
Sources: Associated Press via NPR, 9 May 2026; Reuters via Defense News, 11 May 2026.
Synthetic-opioid deaths
The Year 1 archive records 47,500. CDC's 13 May 2026 provisional estimate was 38,084 deaths involving synthetic opioids in 2025, versus 48,913 in 2024. The category includes but is not limited to fentanyl. The live metric now shows that source's 95.3% arithmetic progress against the agreed 50,000-to-37,500 benchmark; it is not a like-for-like fentanyl-only comparison or evidence of presidential causation.
Sources: CDC provisional 2025 drug overdose data table, 13 May 2026.
Violent-crime target progress
The Year 1 archive's 100% progress and -18% change are not comparable to the agreed 400-per-100,000 baseline. The Council on Criminal Justice reports offence-specific changes across varying city samples, not one overall violent-crime rate. The live metric no longer presents a target-progress percentage or an unsupported causal attribution.
Sources: Council on Criminal Justice, Crime Trends in U.S. Cities: Year-End 2025 Update.
DOGE savings and FY2025 fiscal figures
The Year 1 archive's DOGE figures predate the GAO audit. GAO reports $110.34 billion in DOGE-reported savings as of 7 July 2026 (rounded to $110 billion in its highlights) and finds some estimates incorrect or unsupported; it does not certify the total as realised savings. Treasury reports FY2025 outlays of $7.010 trillion, up 4.1%, and a $1.775 trillion deficit, down $42 billion. Annual totals do not establish DOGE-specific cumulative savings against a counterfactual.
Sources: GAO-26-108615, published 6 August 2026; U.S. Treasury FY2025 Combined Statement.
Other measurement limits
The manufacturing comparison mixes a nominal value-added figure with an agreed baseline that has no stated year or price basis; the Federal Reserve's April 2026 G.17 release reports total industrial production 1.4% above its year-earlier level, a separate measure. The GDP target was already below BEA's first estimate of 2024 nominal GDP, published 30 January 2025. FY2025 border encounters are not comparable to the agreed 500,000 benchmark as an observed FY2024 baseline: Pew reports 1,530,523 encounters in FY2024 and 237,538 in FY2025, and the fiscal year includes three pre-inauguration months. The BLS productivity growth rate is not the agreed dollar-per-hour measure. Cited drug-price analysis does not provide a like-for-like result against the $100 benchmark, and the end-of-term deadline has not passed. These corrections do not alter the locked agreement or Year 1 grades.
Sources: Federal Reserve G.17, 15 May 2026; BEA GDP, fourth quarter and annual 2024, advance estimate; Pew Research, border encounters, 2 February 2026; BLS, Productivity and Costs; Forbes, analysis of typical out-of-pocket drug costs, 5 October 2025.
The grades
What the letters mean.
- A
- Target met or exceeded, plausibly attributable to administration policy.
- B
- Target met or significant progress, with caveats (timing, attribution, method).
- C
- Some progress but well short of target, or target met only because baseline was already near it.
- D
- Minimal progress. The promise has effectively stalled.
- F
- Broken promise. Worse than baseline, or the deadline has demonstrably passed.
The data
Show the working.
The agreed wording is the November 2024 list as written, including US spelling. Two em dashes are shown as colons (metrics 5 and 11). Nothing else has been changed. All money is in US dollars.
Year 1, 24/05/2026: Recorded on 15/11/2026 from the Year 1 assessment published on 24/05/2026. Grades, figures and verdicts are as published that day, except two DOGE figures corrected on 15/11/2026: the verified share of DOGE's claim (published as about 30%) and the source of the $135 billion estimate (published as a CBS analysis). Source lists are as shown on the site on 15/11/2026, including links corrected or added after publication.
The register (JSON) · The check-ins (JSON) · The Year 1 report · Methodology